Get an Insurance Quote from Seibel Insurance’s Dependable Companies

Whether you are shopping for insurance or just checking to see if your current price is still reasonable, click below to get an insurance quote from any of the excellent companies that Seibel represents.

We select our insurance providers with your needs in mind. The insurance coverage we offer is reasonably priced, with protections that fit your unique situation. Moreover, you can depend on the companies we represent to pay your claim if the time ever comes when you need to make one.

However, not all insurance companies operate in the same way. That is why we pick and choose which carriers we represent. You can trust the Seibel Insurance Providers to be among the top companies in price, coverage and service.

We determine the best companies out there and guide you towards which companies provide the coverage and service levels you need.


Find Out More About Each Company

We’ve included information on each company to help you select the one right for you.


Erie Insurance:

Erie insurance logo

We love writing Erie insurance because we always know that Erie stands behind the policies that they write. Erie, a superior-rated, 88-year-old company, offers all lines of insurance and is as good as their claim to “Be Above All in Service”.

Get a quote

Progressive Insurance:

Progressive Insurance

Get the low-price advantages of Progressive with a Seibel agent to advise you. Progressive insures autos, homes, motorcycles, boats, commercial autos and a wide variety of vehicles. Need to insure a Segway? A Classic Car? Progressive has you covered.

Get a quote

Travelers Insurance:

Travelers Insurance

Travelers is a leader in the insurance industry with such innovations as writing the first auto policy, writing space travel policies and providing a hybrid car insurance discount to auto policyholders. This 150-year-old company is waiting to provide a quote for your auto, homeowners, apartment, umbrella coverage, coverage for your wedding or private events and your valuable items.

Get a quote

Madison Mutual:

Madison Mutual Insurance

Madison Mutual is dedicated to selling home, auto and personal lines at competitive prices. Based in Edwardsville, Illinois, it started as an auto insurance company in 1920 – at the beginning of the automobile age. Over 90 years it has focused its coverage in Illinois and Missouri, providing best-in-class personal service to its policyholders.

Get a quote

Mercury Insurance:

Mercury Insurance

If your driving history is exemplary, Mercury insurance is likely to provide some of your best rates. In fact a good driver on average pays 26 percent less with Mercury! They also offer coverage for homes and businesses.

Get a quote

Foremost Insurance:

Foremost Insurance

Owned by Farmers Insurance but underwritten separately, Foremost insurance is a good option for many types of insurance and offers traditional home and auto insurance but also has specialty policies that some other companies don’t handle. We recommend them for clients who must cover mobile homes, boats, off-road vehicles and more. Foremost was the top –rated Illinois insurance company based on having the least consumer complaints in 2010.

Get a quote

Kemper Specialty:

Kemper Specialty Insurance

Kemper Specialty sells auto and commercial auto policies. Their low-cost and alternative auto options — like insuring drivers who have had policies canceled or want to insure a reconditioned vehicle — help Seibel meet the needs of a variety of drivers. Plus their flexible commercial auto insurance grows with your business.

Get a quote

Omni Insurance:

Omni Insurance

Omni insures your auto in a way that won’t cause financial pain, with a low down payment and a payment plan that will fit your budget. They offer great service in both English and Spanish – and can provide same-day proof of coverage.

Get a quote